When designing or remodeling a bathroom, one of the key decisions is whether to install a shower curtain or a shower door. Both options have pros and cons to consider when deciding which is better for your needs. This comprehensive guide examines the key factors to weigh when choosing between a shower curtain or shower door.
Shower Curtain Pros and Cons
Shower curtains are a budget-friendly option, making them a good choice for rentals or bathrooms on a budget. Here are some of the main advantages and disadvantages of shower curtains:
Pros
- Affordable – Shower curtains are significantly less expensive than glass shower doors. A basic vinyl shower curtain can cost as little as $10-20. More stylish fabric shower curtains range from $30-100.
- Easy to Install – Shower curtains are very simple to put up, only requiring shower curtain rods or tension rods secured to the walls. No special tools or hardware needed.
- Variety of Styles – Shower curtains come in a huge range of colors, patterns, materials like vinyl, fabric, or plastic. This allows you to easily match your bathroom decor.
- Flexible – Shower curtains can be fully opened or pulled to one side. This flexibility makes it easier to get in and out of the shower.
- Easy Maintenance – Shower curtains are removable and machine washable. This allows for easy cleaning and replacement when worn out.
Cons
- Prone to Mildew – The moisture in the shower can cause mildew to build up on shower curtains. Proper ventilation is key.
- Gets Soiled Easily – Shower splashes and moisture can quickly lead to stained and soiled shower curtains. White vinyl curtains easily show dirt.
- Billows Inward – Standard shower curtains have nothing to hold them in place, so they tend to blow around and billow inward when the shower is on.
- Less Durability – Most standard plastic or vinyl shower curtains last 6-12 months with regular use until needing replacement.
- Less Visually Appealing – Shower curtains have a more utilitarian look vs. the sleek style of glass doors. The plastic material simply isn’t as refined.
Shower Door Pros and Cons
Shower doors create a more polished, upscale look in a bathroom. However, they come at a higher cost. Here are the main pros and cons of shower doors:
Pros
- Sleek, Modern Look – Frameless glass shower doors have a very clean, contemporary style perfect for modern bathrooms. They look more high-end than a basic shower curtain.
- Increased Durability – Shower doors are built to last much longer than shower curtains. With proper care, high-quality shower doors can last 10-15 years or longer.
- Better Water Containment – Shower doors form a solid barrier that helps contain water spray inside the shower. This keeps the bathroom floor drier than a shower curtain.
- Easier to Keep Clean – Shower doors resist soap scum and mildew better than fabric curtains. Just squeegee and wipe down after showering.
- More Light and Space – Shower doors don’t take up interior space like curtains. This creates a more open, airy shower area.
Cons
- Higher Cost – Shower doors range from $200 on the very low end, up to $1000+ for custom glass doors. The hardware, framing and glass make them a pricey investment.
- Professional Installation – Most homeowners cannot install shower doors on their own. You’ll need to hire a handyman or contractor, adding to the total cost.
- Limit Mobility – Shower doors don’t offer the flexible open access of a curtain. The fixed panels and doors can limit mobility.
- Prone to Smudges – Glass shower doors easily show water spots, fingerprints and smears. They require frequent wiping down.
- Less Privacy – Shower curtains provide full privacy. Glass doors have visible gaps, reducing privacy from some angles. Adding frosted glass can help.
Key Factors to Consider
When deciding between a shower curtain or shower door, keep these key considerations in mind:
Bathroom Size
Smaller bathrooms – A shower curtain is likely the better choice in small bathrooms. Shower doors require additional space to fully open and for the door tracks. Curtains only need a few inches.
Larger bathrooms – If you have ample floor space, shower doors can maximize the feeling of openness. Make sure to measure carefully before purchasing doors.
Budget
Tight budget – It’s hard to beat the affordability and value of a good shower curtain. Inexpensive curtains help keep remodeling costs down.
Premium bathroom – If aiming for a luxury, spa-like bathroom, frameless glass shower doors match the upscale style better than a fabric curtain.
Style Preferences
Modern, sleek look – The clean lines and minimal framing of frameless glass doors complement modern design well.
Traditional style – Classic clawfoot tubs often pair better with fabric shower curtains than modern glass doors.
Bold colors/patterns – Want a punch of color or vibrant tropical print? The wide selection of shower curtain styles and fabrics allow for this customization.
Maintenance Factors
Convenience – Shower curtains are easier to quickly replace and keep clean. Shower doors require more frequent wiping down.
Mildew concerns – In moist environments, shower curtains tend to mildew faster than glass doors. Proper ventilation can help.
Hard water buildup – Hard water causes spotting and mineral buildup on glass shower doors, requiring regular cleaning.
Functional Preferences
Flexible access needed – Shower curtains can be fully opened or moved to one side for easier in/out access.
Contain water splashes – Shower doors provide a better water barrier, keeping splashes inside compared to standard curtains.
Prefer an enclosed feel – Shower doors create a more enclosed, sealed showering space than an open curtain.
Shower Curtain Types
There are a few main types of shower curtains to consider:
Standard Shower Curtains
The most widely used option, standard shower curtains are rectangular sheets of plastic, vinyl or fabric that hang from spring loaded or straight rods. They come in solid colors or endless decorative styles.
Pros – Inexpensive, easy to install, wide variety of colors/patterns
Cons – Prone to billowing in, limited containment of water splashes
Weighted Shower Curtains
Weighted shower curtains or “waffle” shower curtains have magnets or weighted hems to help hold them in place better.
Pros – Better containment, less billowing
Cons – Can be heavier and prone to pulling down rods
Shower Curtain Liners
People often use a clear plastic liner hung inside a decorative outer shower curtain. The liner contains the water while the outer curtain provides style.
Pros – Combines aesthetics and functional water barrier
Cons – Two curtains can feel crowded, liner cleaning hassle
Sliding Shower Curtains
These feature rings or glides that slide along a rod rather than wrapping around it. This helps reduce billowing.
Pros – Enhanced mobility, easier access
Cons – Still less containment than doors, can jump the track
Shower Door Types
If choosing a shower door, you’ll need to pick the right style and glass type:
Frameless/Semi-Frameless
Frameless glass doors have a clean, contemporary style perfect for modern bathrooms. Hinges and joints are minimal.
Pros – Sleek look, unobstructed entry/exit
Cons – Most expensive, prone to leaks over time
Framed Shower Doors
Framed doors have more noticeable metal edging surrounding the glass panels and door. The frame provides stability.
Pros – More affordable, durable and leak-proof
Cons – Obstructed view, bulky frames
Frosted or Clear Glass
Frosted glass provides more privacy while clear glass has a more open feel. Consider combining the two.
Pros – Privacy and style preferences
Cons – None, just personal choice
Swinging vs. Sliding
Most shower doors either swing open into the bathroom or slide along the entry. Consider clearance needs.
Pros – Entry/exit and space preferences
Cons – None, just based on layout
Key Installation and Design Tips
Proper installation and design are critical to maximize the benefits of shower doors and curtains. Follow these tips:
- Measure carefully before purchasing shower curtains or doors to ensure a proper watertight fit. Leave ampleoverlap over the tub edges.
- Opt for wider shower curtain rods (60-72 inches wide) to minimize billowing and keep the shower fully accessible.
- Use shower doors with watertight seals along the edges and bottom to limit leaks. Install on a perfectly plum, level surface.
- Improve shower curtain containment with extenders that press the curtain outward against the walls. Or add corner curtain rods to fully enclose the area.
- Choose sliding doors or hinged doors that open outward for easiest entry/exit if your bathroom floorplan allows it.
- Install quality ventilation fans and humidity-resistant ceiling fansto minimize moisture buildup that causes mildew on shower curtains.
- Select mildew-resistant vinyl or polyester shower curtains and plastic liners to limit mildew growth in humid climates.
- Squeegee glass shower doors after each use and wipe down with glass cleaner weekly to keep them spotless. Rinse shower curtains monthly with diluted vinegar.
- Use a sealant like Rain-X on glass shower doors to make water bead up and wipe off easier after showering. Reapply every 2-3 months.
Cost Comparison
On average, here are typical costs for basic shower curtains versus shower doors:
- Shower curtain – $10-$30 for a vinyl shower curtain; $30-$120 for a fabric shower curtain; $20 for curtain liner; $25 for curtain rod
- Shower door – $200-$800 for framed glass doors; $800-$1500+ for frameless doors; $100+ for professional installation
As you can see, shower doors generally cost at least 5-10x more than a shower curtain setup. The glass material, hardware and professional installation add to the total expense. However, shower doors also tend to last 5-10 years longer than basic vinyl curtains when cared for properly.
Shower Curtain or Shower Door: Which is Better For You?
If affordable cost and simple installation are your priorities, a shower curtain can’t be beat. They offer endless style options at a budget-friendly price point.
However, if you want a truly upscale, spa-like bathroom with maximum water containment, a frameless glass shower door system brings an airy, contemporary look.
Take the time to carefully weigh your bathroom space, budget, decor style and functional needs. This will determine whether a stylish new shower curtain or sleek frameless door is the ideal choice for your home. With the right selection, you’ll enjoy an invigorating, relaxing shower experience for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for small bathrooms, a shower curtain or door?
For small bathrooms, a shower curtain is generally the smarter choice. Shower doors require ample clearance space to fully open and accommodate the door tracks properly. Standard shower curtains only need a couple inches of clearance on each side.
Do shower doors really contain water better than curtains?
Yes, shower doors form a solid barrier that retains water spray and humidity inside the shower area better than a fabric curtain. Shower curtains allow steam, mist and splashes to escape around the edges. However, weighted “waffle” shower curtains can improve containment.
How difficult is it to install shower doors?
In most cases, hiring a professional is recommended to install shower doors properly. The doors need to be perfectly measured and leveled, with watertight seals along the edges and base. Improper installation can lead to water leaks and other issues.
Should I get clear or frosted glass for my shower door?
Clear glass provides an airier, more open feel but can lack privacy. Frosted glass obscures views in and out while allowing light. Combining frosted and clear panels can achieve privacy while maintaining visibility.
How do I keep my shower doors clean and spot-free?
Squeegeeing after each use prevents water buildup. For weekly deep cleaning, spray with a non-abrasive cleaner and wipe down. Rain-X or other sealants also prevent streaks and spots by making water bead up and roll off the glass.
How often do shower curtains need to be replaced?
On average, vinyl shower curtains last about 6 to 12 months with frequent use before needing replacement. Regular mildew removal and washing can extend their lifespan. High quality fabric shower curtains can last several years with proper maintenance.
What’s the best way to limit mildew on shower curtains?
Mildew thrives in moist environments. Ensure your bathroom has adequate ventilation fans and humidity control. Choose mildew-resistant vinyl or polyester curtains. Clean frequently with solutions of white vinegar or lemon juice. Avoid leaving the curtain closed between showers.
Can I install shower doors myself or do I need to hire a pro?
It is highly advisable to hire a skilled contractor to install shower doors. The door panels are heavy, fragile, and require very precise alignment and watertight seals to prevent leakage. Handle installation is complex. Mistakes can be costly.
How much privacy do glass shower doors offer?
Shower doors allow some visibility from certain angles, reducing privacy versus a curtain. Using frosted glass panels provides obscured views. Also make sure door handles have a locking mechanism.
Should I get sliding or swinging shower doors?
If your bathroom layout accommodates it, outward opening swinging doors are typically easiest for entry and exit. Sliding doors save a bit more space but you have to fully open them to get in or out.
Conclusion
When it comes to choosing shower curtains vs. shower doors, consider your bathroom layout, budget, personal style, and functional needs. Standard shower curtains provide affordable style and easy access but have some downsides. Professional installed glass shower doors offer upscale appeal with maximum water containment, albeit at a higher price. Carefully weigh the pros and cons of both options to make the optimal choice for your home and lifestyle needs. With some smart planning upfront, you’ll enjoy a relaxing shower experience.
