Deciding between a freestanding tub and a built-in tub for your bathroom remodel or new construction project is an important choice that can impact your budget, layout, and enjoyment of your space. Here is an overview of the key differences, pros and cons of each option to help you determine which is better for your needs.
Key Differences Between Freestanding and Built-In Tubs
Installation: Freestanding tubs are not connected to the floor or walls. They stand alone on legs and require minimal plumbing. Built-in tubs integrate with the surrounding flooring and walls, requiring more installation work.
Layout Flexibility: Freestanding tubs can be positioned anywhere there is adequate floor space and plumbing access. Built-in tubs are limited to alcoves or platforms designed specifically for them.
Customization: Freestanding tubs come in set dimensions and styles. Built-in tubs can be fully customized to your exact specifications.
Weight Support: Freestanding tubs have feet that distribute weight directly to the floor. Built-in tubs rely on a well-constructed platform for weight distribution and support.
Cost: Freestanding tubs tend to be more affordable than custom built-in tubs and installations. However, built-ins may increase home value more.
Pros of Choosing a Freestanding Tub
Easy Installation: Freestanding tubs simply need connecting to water supply and drain lines, reducing installation time and costs.
Layout Flexibility: Their independence from walls allows for creative layouts. Place them in the center of a space for a focal point.
Affordability: factory-made freestanding tubs are generally less expensive than built-in options, especially when factoring in custom tile work.
Portability: Freestanding tubs can be taken with you to a new home or relocated if you remodel. Built-in tubs cannot be moved.
Variety of Materials: Freestanding tubs come in acrylic, stone, copper, cast iron, and other materials to suit your style.
Soaking Experience: Their exposed sides create an immersive bathing experience. Add a tray for bath salts, oils, or candles to enhance relaxation.
Pros of Choosing a Built-In Tub
Customization: Built-in tubs can be made to your exact specifications for size, shape, depth, and material.
Spa Experience: When combined with custom tile, stone or solid surface surrounds, built-ins create an upscale, spa-like vibe.
Space Optimization: Built-ins can be designed to perfectly fit an existing tub alcove, utilizing the space efficiently.
Added Home Value: Upscale custom built-in tubs and well-constructed surrounds increase a home’s value more than freestanding tubs.
Easy Access: Built-in tubs generally have low or no rims, making entering and exiting easier. Some include integral seating or armrests as well.
Durability: Tile or solid surface surrounds are extremely durable. Fiberglass and acrylic built-in tubs also resist scratches and dents.
Key Considerations When Choosing Between Freestanding and Built-In Tubs
Budget: Built-ins often cost significantly more when factoring in custom construction and finishes.
Bathing Needs: Consider ergonomic features like low entry and seating for accessibility. Freestanding tubs rarely offer these.
Plumbing Location: Built-ins limit you to areas with existing plumbing. Freestanding tubs allow more flexibility.
Tub Use Frequency: Occasional users may prefer style and soaking. Frequent bathers may want comfort and accessibility.
Available Space: Measure thoroughly. Freestanding tubs need more open floor space. Built-ins need an alcove or platform.
Design Style: Freestanding tubs suit vintage, rustic, or eclectic spaces well. Built-ins excel in contemporary, elegant, or minimalist designs.
Conclusion
The choice between a freestanding tub versus a built-in tub depends on your budget, design style, bathing needs and preferences. Freestanding tubs provide flexibility in placement, are quicker to install, and lower cost but don’t allow for customization. Built-in tubs can be tailored to your space, create a spa-like experience and increase home value but are more expensive. Measure your space, weigh the pros and cons, and choose the option that best suits your bathrooms design and function. With high quality materials and professional installation, either tub choice can provide an enjoyable, eye-catching focal point in your bathroom retreat.
