Deciding between granite or quartz countertop overlays can be a difficult choice. Both materials have their advantages and disadvantages that are important to consider when selecting a new overlay for your kitchen or bathroom countertops. This article will compare granite and quartz overlays to help you determine which is the better option for your home renovation project.
Overview of Granite and Quartz Countertops
Granite countertops are made from large slabs of natural stone that are cut and polished to create a beautiful, unique pattern. Granite is an igneous rock that forms when magma cools slowly beneath the earth’s surface. It’s composed primarily of quartz and feldspar minerals, making it very hard and durable.
Quartz countertops are engineered stone made from crushed quartz particles combined with resins and pigments. The resin binds the quartz together to create a manmade slab. Quartz offers consistent coloring and patterning since it is engineered rather than natural stone.
Both granite and quartz make excellent choices for kitchen and bathroom countertops. They are resistant to scratches, stains, heat, and moisture. However, there are some key differences between the two materials.
Pros and Cons of Granite Countertop Overlays
Pros:
- Completely unique natural stone patterns and colors
- Can last a lifetime with proper care
- Adds value to your home
- Resistant to heat, scratches and stains
- Available in a wide variety of colors and patterns
Cons:
- More expensive than quartz
- Requires periodic sealing to prevent stains
- Can chip if subjected to heavy impact
- Natural fissures may be present in some slabs
- Porous surface can harbor bacteria if not properly sealed
Cost of Granite Overlays
Granite countertop overlays typically cost $50-100 per square foot installed. The price varies based on the granite slab selected. More exotic, rare granite varieties will be on the higher end of this price spectrum.
Granite requires professional installation, which also adds to the total project cost. Expect to pay an additional $40-75 per hour for fabrication and installation.
Pros and Cons of Quartz Countertop Overlays
Pros:
- Requires very little maintenance
- Consistent coloring throughout the slab
- Non-porous so it resists staining
- Durable and scratch-resistant
- Easy to clean
- Some varieties have antimicrobial properties
Cons:
- Less customization options than natural stone
- Joints may be more visible
- Doesn’t have the uniqueness of natural granite
- Doesn’t add as much value to home as granite
Cost of Quartz Overlays
Quartz countertop overlays range in price from $70-120 per square foot installed. This cost includes materials and professional installation.
The price depends on the brand and variety of quartz selected, as well as local labor costs. On average, expect to pay $100 per square foot for a mid-range quartz overlay.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Granite and Quartz
When deciding between granite vs quartz for your countertop overlay, keep the following factors in mind:
- Budget – Quartz is generally more affordable than granite
- Maintenance – Quartz requires very little upkeep compared to granite
- Aesthetics – Granite offers more customization and natural patters
- Durability – Both materials are very durable for heavy use
- Sanitation – Quartz resists bacteria growth better than natural stone
- Resale Value – Granite may increase home value more than quartz
Take time to view granite and quartz slabs in person at local stone suppliers. This will give you a better idea of the available colors, patterns and finishes. Be sure to ask about seams, edging options, and warranties.
Get estimates from more than one fabricator to compare pricing. A good fabricator will also guide you through the entire process from template and installation to sealing and maintenance.
Frequently Asked Questions About Granite and Quartz Overlays
Which is better for kitchen countertops?
Both granite and quartz make excellent kitchen countertops that can handle heavy daily use. Quartz requires less maintenance since it doesn’t need periodic sealing. Granite offers more customization options for a unique look. For busy kitchens, quartz may be better since it is non-porous and resists staining.
Is a granite or quartz overlay cheaper than full countertop replacement?
Yes, overlays are a more affordable option for upgrading countertops without full replacement. Exact pricing depends on which material you choose and the size of the project, but overlays generally cost $50-120 per square foot installed.
Can you put a granite or quartz overlay over existing laminate countertops?
It is possible to install a thin granite or quartz overlay over laminate. The existing countertop must be in good condition with no warping or damage. The overlay is adhered with a strong bonding adhesive to create a smooth, seamless surface.
How thick are granite and quartz overlays?
Standard thicknesses for granite and quartz overlays are 1/4 inch to 3/4 inch. Thinner overlays under 1/2 inch are considered medium thickness. The thicker the overlay, the more durable and resistant to damage it will be. Most homeowners choose a 3/4 inch overlay.
Should I choose matte or gloss finish for a granite or quartz overlay?
This depends on your personal preference. Gloss finishes offer more shine and reflection, while matte or honed finishes have a soft, textured look. Matte granite and quartz are better at hiding fingerprints and water marks from daily use. A combination of glossy and matte areas can provide contrast.
Conclusion
When deciding between installing a new granite vs quartz countertop overlay, weigh the pros and cons of each carefully. Granite offers natural beauty and customization, while quartz is lower maintenance. For most homeowners, the choice comes down to the visual appeal of each material and how it fits your lifestyle and budget. Consult a professional fabricator to ensure proper installation and care. With either option, you’ll end up with beautiful new countertops that add value and luxury to your kitchen or bath.
